A random discussion about magic


There's no time for a long debate

This might end up being a random tirade, but let's see where it goes. Let's talk a bit about magic. In fiction, magic is a concept that can take many different forms, as it loosely refers to any phenomenon that wouldn't occur in the natural world. I know it might sound strange coming from someone as heavily science-minded as I am, but I truly think that fiction is the perfect medium for exploring the bounds of what's possible in reality. Needless to say, I watch and read a lot of fantasy stories.

Trying too hard to sound significant

What I'm really trying to get at with this post is along the lines of how I prefer to see magic used in a story. To be clear, I'm not saying there's a right way to do it. I'm no expert, after all. Given how we approach scientific investigation, it's probably tempting to say that a series must always explain the mechanisms behind its magic, but I don't think it's quite so simple.

Glenn claims to be an expert

That's not to say that a complicated magical system can't be interesting. Many series that involve magical academies tend to leverage this idea. A show like Rokudenashi Majutsu Koushi to Akashic Records relies on this fact, as the main character, Glenn, breaks many social magic conventions in order to optimize his spells. Discovering what kind of spells can be cast in this system is part of what makes a show like that interesting.

Shiro thinks you're too negative

In contrast, xxxHOLiC is one of my favorite shows of all time, and it has a magic system that I find confusing. However, I don't think this fact is particularly important, because the main point of the story is to show that the supernatural doesn't solve all problems. The series revolves around the concept of destiny or inevitability, and emphasizes the sacrifice required to get what you want with magic.

The siren goes off

If I were to truly distill my opinion down, I think I just prefer that magic feels as natural as possible in the world that's being presented. My views tend to focus more on how the concept relates to the plot rather than how much it's built. In Spice and Wolf, Holo can transform into a giant wolf to solve most of Lawrence's problems, but doing so exposes her to persecution from the Church. The fact that she can't do so lightly forces the main characters to approach problems realistically while using magic as an absolute last resort.

Bocchi is being suspicious again

Where I think this can go wrong is in a series like Clannad, specifically in Clannad: After Story. While the series does a lot of things well, it has a minor supernatural element that's never truly addressed until the very end. And when it does, the magical element appears to completely save the day, without any real provocation. As a result, it gives the impression that it exists only to create a better ending, which has always bothered me.

Anne gets it all wrong

Well, that ended up being a lot longer than I expected, but that's all I have for now. Be sure to let me know how you feel about magic in anime. What do you like to see from fantasy or supernatural shows? Also, feel free to let me know if I'm just being overly nitpicky again. I deserve it.



  • Yualexius

    June 8, 2019, 9:03 a.m.

    Well, if we talk about magic in anime I always thought of it as something big or grand. Maybe, that is why I am big fan of The Ancient Magus' Bride, and similar shows. Though Eastern mysticism or supernatural stories really enchanted me just like every episode of Natsume Yuujinchou always ended up so magical and emotional even in slightest way for me. I think the most bizzare or confusing magic stuffs in anime that I may like the least is those magic merged with science as I really have the problem of differenciating those two when they're being presented in one story with so many holes.

    Reply

    marthaurion

    June 8, 2019, 9:47 a.m.

    ive always found eastern supernatural myths to be fascinating as well, and i tend to gravitate towards those show. and i agree that shows which mix science and magic tend to be much more questionable

    Reply

Leave a comment

b i u quote


© 2011-2019 Marth's Anime Blog | Powered by Marth's Free Time